Who Should Be Arsenals Next Captain?

Who Should Be Arsenals Next Captain? It’s a debate that always sparks passionate discussions among Gunners fans. The captain’s armband at Arsenal carries a legacy of legendary leaders, from Tony Adams and Patrick Vieira to more recent figures like Cesc Fàbregas and Martin Ødegaard. As Mikel Arteta continues shaping his squad for long-term success, the question remains: who is the best candidate to lead the team moving forward? With experienced contenders and rising stars in the mix, let’s dive into the debate and analyse who should be Arsenal’s next captain.

What Makes a Great Arsenal Captain?

The captaincy at Arsenal is more than just wearing the armband—it’s about embodying the club’s values and leading by example on and off the pitch. From Tony Adams’ warrior spirit to Patrick Vieira’s commanding presence, Arsenal’s greatest leaders have shared common traits that define a true captain.

Key Traits of a Great Arsenal Captain

🔴 Leadership on and off the pitch – A captain must inspire their teammates in both high-pressure situations and behind the scenes, setting the tone for professionalism and commitment.

⚡ Passion and commitment to the club – Arsenal’s best captains have always had an unwavering love for the badge. Fans want a leader who bleeds red and white and understands what it means to play for Arsenal.

🗣 Strong communication and influence – Whether rallying teammates during tough matches or maintaining morale in the dressing room, a captain must be a vocal presence that teammates respect.

🧠 Composure under pressure – Arsenal’s captain needs to stay calm in big moments, handle media responsibilities, and be a bridge between players, the manager, and the fans.

🏆 Experience and tactical intelligence – While youth can bring energy, leadership often comes with experience. The ability to read the game, motivate the team, and make quick decisions on the pitch is crucial.

Some of Arsenal’s greatest captains had all these qualities, while others grew into the role over time. So, who in the current squad possesses these attributes and deserves to be Arsenal’s next captain? Let’s break down the leading candidates.

The Main Contenders for Arsenal’s Next Captain

With Arsenal’s squad packed with talent and leadership potential, the battle for the captain’s armband is a heated debate among fans. Whether it’s an experienced leader, a vocal presence, or a player who leads by example, Mikel Arteta has several strong candidates to choose from.

🏅 Martin Ødegaard – The Trusted Playmaker

Current Captain | Age: 25 | Position: Attacking Midfielder

✅ Pros:

• Already wearing the armband and trusted by Arteta.
• Leads by example with his work rate and technical brilliance.
• Strong connection with younger players and embodies Arsenal’s philosophy.

❌ Cons:

• Not the most vocal leader; some question if he commands enough presence in tough moments.
• Arsenal has seen quiet captains before (e.g., Fabregas, van Persie)—will he be different?

Ødegaard has been at the heart of Arsenal’s resurgence, dictating play and setting high standards. But should the captaincy stay with him long-term, or is there a stronger leader in the squad?

⚡ Declan Rice – The Natural Leader

Captain Potential | Age: 25 | Position: Defensive Midfielder

✅ Pros:

• Former West Ham captain, led them to European glory.
• Vocal leader, commands respect, and organizes the midfield.
• Plays in a key position that sees everything on the pitch.

❌ Cons:

• Still relatively new to the squad—does he need more time to establish himself?
• Might benefit from focusing on his performances without additional responsibility.

Rice is the kind of captain that leads from the trenches, constantly talking, motivating, and setting standards. His leadership credentials are undeniable, but is it too soon to hand him the armband?

🛡 Gabriel Magalhães – The Warrior at the Back

Captain Material | Age: 26 | Position: Centre-Back

✅ Pros:

• Vocal, passionate, and brings fire to Arsenal’s defense.
• Arsenal’s most dominant center-back, physically and mentally strong.
• Fights for every ball and never shies away from tough battles.

❌ Cons:

• Can sometimes be too emotional, which leads to rash decisions.
• Not the most fluent English speaker, which could be a barrier to communication.

Gabriel wears his heart on his sleeve and has the physicality and attitude of a classic Arsenal captain. But is he the best choice when there are other strong leaders in the team?

🔥 Bukayo Saka – The Hale End Hero

Future Captain? | Age: 22 | Position: Winger

✅ Pros:

• Arsenal through and through—a leader by example.
• One of the most consistent performers in the squad.
• Universally respected by teammates and fans.

❌ Cons:

• A quiet personality, not the most vocal on the pitch.
• Already carries massive responsibility—would the armband be too much?

Saka represents everything Arsenal stands for, and one day, he could wear the armband. But is it the right time for him, or should he focus on being Arsenal’s attacking talisman?

🌟 Myles Lewis-Skelly – The Star of the Far Future

One for the Future | Age: 18 | Position: Midfielder / Left-Back

✅ Pros:

• Highly rated Hale End graduate, likened to legendary Arsenal midfielders.
• Confident, mature beyond his years, and already showing leadership qualities.
• Could follow in the footsteps of Cesc Fabregas as a young Arsenal captain.

❌ Cons:

• Still developing and learning—needs time to establish himself in the first team.
• Could benefit from focusing on his growth rather than leadership responsibilities.

Lewis-Skelly is seen as a future leader, but his time for the captaincy is still a long way off. If he continues his trajectory, he could be the face of Arsenal’s leadership in years to come.

Who Should Lead Arsenal Forward?

With so many strong candidates, the decision isn’t easy. Should Arsenal stick with Ødegaard’s technical leadership, hand the armband to a vocal warrior like Rice or Gabriel, or groom Saka for the role?

👉 Who do you think should be Arsenal’s next captain? Drop your vote and comment below! 🔴⚪

What the Fans Are Saying

Arsenal fans are split on who should be Arsenal’s next captain, with discussions across social media and forums highlighting different perspectives. Many supporters back Martin Ødegaard to continue as captain, arguing that he embodies Arteta’s philosophy, leads by example, and has already proven himself in the role. However, some believe he lacks the vocal authority traditionally expected from an Arsenal skipper.

A large section of the fanbase is pushing for Declan Rice, citing his natural leadership, communication on the pitch, and past experience as West Ham captain. His commanding presence in midfield and ability to drive the team forward make him a strong contender, though some feel he should settle further into the squad before taking the armband.

Gabriel Magalhães has a loyal following among fans who admire his passion, aggression, and defensive leadership. His emotional connection with the game is both a strength and a concern, with some questioning whether his temperament is suited for the role.

While Bukayo Saka is seen as Arsenal’s long-term leader, many believe he is still too young and carries enough responsibility already. Fans appreciate his professionalism and influence but acknowledge that he is more of a role model than a vocal captain.

Interestingly, Myles Lewis-Skelly is starting to gain recognition as a potential leader for the future, with academy watchers highlighting his composure and maturity beyond his years.

Overall, the debate is ongoing, with many fans happy to see Ødegaard remain captain but open to Rice or Gabriel stepping up in the future.

Expert Opinions & Former Player Insights

The Arsenal captaincy debate has drawn input from former players, pundits, and football analysts, each with their own take on who is best suited to lead the team.

Legendary Arsenal captain Tony Adams has always emphasized the importance of a captain being a commanding presence, particularly in defence. He has often spoken about the need for a leader who is not only vocal but also willing to take responsibility when things get tough. If following Adams’ philosophy, William Saliba could be an interesting long-term option. The Frenchman is calm, composed, and already one of Arsenal’s most important players at just 23. Some believe that if he develops his leadership skills, he could be the ideal captain to marshal the defence in the years to come.

Meanwhile, Cesc Fàbregas, who captained Arsenal at a young age, believes that a modern captain doesn’t have to be the loudest but must be the team’s driving force. He sees Martin Ødegaard as the ideal leader in this sense—someone who influences games, maintains composure, and sets the example for the team’s playing style. Former Gunner Aaron Ramsey has also spoken highly of Ødegaard’s leadership, highlighting how his consistency and professionalism have helped Arsenal grow into title contenders.

However, some ex-players believe Arsenal could benefit from a more traditional English-style captain. Roy Keane, while never an Arsenal player, has argued that Premier League captains should be fiery and demanding. If that’s the case, Declan Rice is a natural fit. His leadership at West Ham, combined with his ability to rally teammates, makes him a strong candidate. Emmanuel Petit has also praised Rice for his on-pitch communication and energy, noting that Arsenal has lacked a midfield general since Vieira.

Another wildcard option that some pundits have floated is Ben White. While not the most obvious choice, White is a no-nonsense defender, versatile, and extremely reliable. Former Arsenal defender Lee Dixon has mentioned that players like White, who have a fearless approach and put their body on the line, often make great leaders even if they aren’t the loudest in the dressing room.

The consensus from experts is clear: Ødegaard remains the safest choice, Saliba could grow into the role, Rice has the vocal presence Arsenal might need, and White could be a surprise contender. The debate continues, but one thing is certain—Arsenal has no shortage of leaders in their squad.

The Verdict: Who Should Lead Arsenal?

After weighing up all the options, the best course for Arsenal’s captaincy seems to be a continuation with Martin Ødegaard—at least until the end of the 2025/26 season. Ødegaard has grown into the role, earning Arteta’s full trust while leading Arsenal’s charge toward silverware. His influence on the pitch, professionalism, and ability to set the tone for the team’s playing style make him a strong captain in the current setup.

However, football is a results-driven game, and captains are ultimately judged by their ability to lead a team to success. If Arsenal fail to lift a major trophy by the end of the 2025/26 season, it may be time for a change in leadership—one that brings a more passionate, vocal presence to the armband. In that case, Gabriel Magalhães stands out as the ideal candidate.

The Brazilian defender embodies the raw emotion, aggression, and vocal leadership that some fans believe Arsenal currently lack in big moments. He is a warrior at the back, always willing to fight for the badge, and his presence could inject an added layer of intensity into the squad. His ability to organize the defence, rally teammates, and express his passion could make him the perfect leader if Arsenal need a fresh voice.

For now, Ødegaard remains the right man to wear the armband, but if Arsenal are still falling short by 2026, a shift to Gabriel’s fiery, vocal leadership might be exactly what the club needs to take the next step.

Have Your Say!

The captaincy debate is far from settled, and we want to hear from you! Who should be Arsenal’s next captain? Should Ødegaard continue leading the team until Arsenal finally lift silverware, or is it time for a more vocal presence like Gabriel to take the armband? Maybe you believe Declan Rice, William Saliba, or even a surprise contender should step up?

🔴 Vote Now!
📊 Poll: Who should be Arsenal’s next captain?
1️⃣ Martin Ødegaard – Keep him in charge until at least 2026
2️⃣ Gabriel Magalhães – Passion, aggression, and leadership
3️⃣ Declan Rice – A natural leader with a winning mentality
4️⃣ William Saliba – Calm, composed, and a defensive rock
5️⃣ Other – Comment your choice below!

💬 Join the Debate!
Drop your thoughts in the comments! Do Arsenal need a vocal leader, or is a captain who leads by example the way forward? Let’s hear your arguments and predictions!

📢 Follow us for more Arsenal debates, match analysis, and exclusive content!